Monday, January 19, 2009

Surgeon demands kidney or $1.5 million


NEW YORK: A New York surgeon who donated a kidney to his now estranged wife, is demanding the organ be returned.
Doctor Richard Batista decided to ask for his kidney back after nearly four years of divorce proceedings.
He says, if he can't get the organ back, he is willing to accept $1.5 million instead.

Batista claims his wife began having an affair two years after he gave her the kidney.
"I felt humiliated, betrayed, disrespected and disregarded as a person, a man,a husband as a father," said Batista.
An attorney for Batista's wife says, the facts of the now public case, have been misrepresented.
A judge is expected to hear the case within the next few days.


The guys in the photo would have loved to get 1.5 million for their kidneys - McKay

32 comments:

KyleMeeks2 said...

1.5 million....or a kidney.

Tough choice....

LorrieH3 said...

Thats pretty sad, but i guess if ur desperate, ull do wat u have 2.

ChristaC3 said...

hmmmm, well I guess I would give up a kidney for 1.5 million. Just not my right one. I'm parsial to that one :)

PhilipB said...

Reminds me of an old saying.... a fool once gave his friend a dollar; now he no longer has that dollar as well as that friend... Even though marriage has a 50 percent chance of ending in a divorce. I applaud this guy's attempt to keep his marriage in shape with the old donate your kidney move....

LathanS3 said...

Ill give the guy my kidney for 1.5 mil if he just wants a kidney

taylorn6 said...

I would give the kidney no questions asked and not just for the money

spruillb said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
spruillb said...

6th
i wonder which hurt more, recovery from surgery, or a divorce from a wife you donated a kidney to?? hmmm....

leighannalogsdon5 said...

talk about a messy divorce...yikes

anjej6 said...

For some odd reason, this reminds me of "Charlie the Unicorn" who goes to the Candy Mountain and gets his liver taken.. aaaanyways--

I'm just wondering-- would the wife die if she was to give back her husband's kidney?

jackkoenig6 said...

anje they took his kidney :-P

lauras6 said...

Wow.

That makes me sad and a bit amused.
But mostly sad...

KalebM 2 said...

On the outside looking in, this story would be a comic's dream. The scenario is somewhat sad..but the guy gave up his kidney on account of his oblivious interpretation regarding cost-benefit analysis. But, then again, that's what makes the whole thing funny in the first place.

MaryH2 said...

Wow. What happens if she can't come up with the money? OR what the heck is he going with the organ if he gets it back? I can't help but laugh at this.

laurene6 said...

I want to know who did the appraisal on the kidney? Are we now pricing organs or blood donations?

mikey bejar said...

kaleb said it all for me. i agree

JordanC2 said...

If this guy can somehow get $1.5 million for his kidney, then i got some body parts i would like to sell.

ashleighsifrit6 said...

Wow. That is a really sad way to treat someone even though they wronged against you. No person in the world should be so cruel and desperate to demand a kidney(given as a gift) to someone you cared deeply about, or give them the option of 1.5 million. This man must hold a lot of things against people if this is the way he reacts to a situation such as this one.

Jeremy.M.5 said...

Wow that's sad. The husband obviously has good reason to feel hurt and disrespected. However, you should not demand a bodily organ to be returned after the kidney was freely donated to save someone's life.

Kevin Louder said...

That's just sad. The wife can either give the kidney back and die or pay him a ridiculous amount of money that she more than likely doesn't even have. What is the world coming to?

Ryan R6 said...

I would donate a kidney for $1.5 million. Dr. Barista just wants to make life miserable for his ex.

cristap6 said...

I don't think that's very good. Ya, he probably feels bad since he gave part of his body so she could live but...really? That's the dumbest thing I've heard. He DONATED his kidney and is now asking for something back that is keeping her alive. Ridiculous

Paula M 2 said...

Wow. People are suing for the most rediculous things these days.

KevinJ3 said...

People will do anything for a easy buck. The fact that he wanted his kidney back is completely rediculous and dumb.

kelleyyandell2 said...

oh my gosh! that is horrible. no one should ever have to make that decision!

Anonymous said...

i think the guys being pretty selfish yeah she was wrong but getting his kidney back wont change what happened or make him happy again

sabrinat2 said...

Wow... that is extremely selfish!
By the way, that picture is a bit disturbing.

little mari said...

The kidney that he gave his wife became her property as soon as he gave it up. It's almost funny that he would want it back, but i guess people will do anything for money.

DamonD6 said...

$1.5 million dollars is a bad deal. Even with all of the surgery and rehabilitation fees theres no way it could've added up to $1.5 million. Doesn't she need the kidney to live?

AmberS6 said...

wow..thats pretty intense.
but i guess you have to do what you have to do.

MadisonA5 said...

He's only asking $1.5 million for the kidney? Is that what he thinks her life is worth?

vspringer said...

Hey if someones asking $1.5 million for a kidney I might have an organ or two I could do without.